The Independent Expert Reports

The Independent Expert Reports

Six independent specialists were commissioned to examine the environmental case behind Yntegra’s approvals for its Rosewood Exuma project on Sampson Cay, Exuma. Their reports were originally prepared for the legal proceedings now before The Supreme Court of The Bahamas.

The reports were also served on the Subdivision and Development Appeal Board, which agreed to admit them and then overturned its own decision, determining that no additional reports would be admitted in evidence. Turtlegrass has appealed.

Now, we are publishing the reports here in full, one at a time.

The reports

01

ANDREW BAKER - Ecology

A UK ecologist of almost forty years, specialising in Environmental Impact Assessment and nature conservation law. He reviewed the Environmental Impact Assessment and Environmental Management Plan behind Yntegra’s approvals and found them “deeply flawed” and was created for a version of the project that is no longer the one proposed, and resting on survey work too limited to describe what is on the site.
02

MARK GASH — Ornithology & international standards

He assesses environmental studies against international standards, and has done so in more than twenty-five countries. Judged against IFC Performance Standard 6 and World Bank ESS6, he found Yntegra’s case “wholly inadequate for a site of this ecological sensitivity,” resting on surveys carried out in a single season. His conclusion: “the decision-maker was not provided with the ecological information necessary to make a properly informed decision, and some of the information that was provided was wrong.”
03

DR CRAIG DAHLGREN — Marine survey — 14 October 2026

He has studied Bahamian marine ecosystems since 1992 and is Executive Director of the Perry Institute for Marine Science. He drone-mapped 155 acres of the North Bay and surveyed it underwater along measured transects, counting corals, fish and conch. He found a working conch nursery close to its reproductive limit, reefs in better condition than most in The Bahamas, and a dredging plan that takes the best of them first. He notes the most significant long-term risk is not just localized habitat loss, but rather the disruption of the physical processes that maintain habitat quality and ecosystem function.
04

CLIVE CARPENTER — Water supply & sewage — 2 November 2026

A hydrogeologist with GWP Consultants and more than 33 years of experience in groundwater, surface water and flood risk, including a three-year assessment of The Bahamas’ national water sector. He reviewed the groundwater and hydrology parts of Yntegra’s Environmental Impact Assessment and found no evidence that anyone had investigated the island itself. The assessment omits brine disposal entirely, underestimates the freshwater beneath the site, and does not assess how pollution from fuel, wastewater and brine would travel through the groundwater to the sea.

EXUMA DESERVES BETTER

Close-up of golden dried grass seeds against a blue sky and blurred water background.Bright orange and yellow sunset over calm ocean water with silhouetted rocky coastline and greenery in the foreground, and two boats near the horizon by the sun.Aerial view of an island with dense green vegetation, a small orange pond, soft white sandy beaches, surrounded by clear turquoise waters and deeper blue ocean under a partly cloudy sky.View of a turquoise sea with varying shades of blue, a white sandy beach, and green shrubbery in the foreground under a blue sky with scattered clouds.

Bahamians have raised many of the concerns outlined in these reports since Yntegra’s Rosewood Exuma project was proposed. These independent experts have now examined this project and reached the same conclusion. The approvals behind it were granted without adequate information and pose a serious risk to the environment of Sampson Cay.

Learn about our fight to defend sampson cay
Sign The Petition